Cholera tragedy in Indian village sheds light on power debts

Village councils fail to pay bills as new water connections increase energy usage, but cash-strapped power companies need the revenue to ensure a steady electricity supply.

Girls collect water from a well in Rajasthan, India. Image: Save the Children, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Flickr.

Clean water had just started sputtering from newly installed taps in Pachdongri village in western India last month when the power supply to the hilly hamlet was cut off for unpaid bills.

Residents link this power outage to a cholera outbreak that followed, claiming five lives.

Pachdongri’s outstanding power bill of 52,000 rupees ($657), pending for about five months, accounts for a tiny part of the huge strain on India’s stressed electricity supply chain, in which power distributors owe $12.52 billion to largely thermal generating companies.

The utilities must pay coal firms upfront to buy the fossil fuel to produce electricity, but are struggling to do so as their cash flow is squeezed due to consumers failing to pay for their power, threatening supply.

As India tries to cut its power sector’s losses with financial aid to utilities and promotion of solar energy in agriculture, the financial stress on the sector has tragically impacted Pachdongri, a village of fewer than 1,000 people.

“If water supply had continued, the deaths could have been avoided as people consumed contaminated water from a well,” said Sanjay Bhuta Jamunkar, 32, the council head for five villages, including Pachdongri, in western Maharashtra state.

We are looking at solar-based water pumps so they don’t require electricity connection to avoid these challenges.

Hrishikesh Yashod, Maharashtra director, Jal Jeevan Mission

Following the cholera outbreak, the government issued orders to utilities not to disconnect the power supply to public water works, and the state is also now considering clearing the debts of village councils, utility officials said.

“This was our first power bill for operating the water pump. We weren’t sure we had to pay it, as work on the water connections was still underway,” said Jamunkar, noting that the council pays bills from the property and water taxes it levies on households.

“But collections are poor as this is a tribal area, people are either landless or small landowners. Many are unemployed. We try to manage,” he told the Thomson Reuters Foundation by phone.

Demand spike

Extreme heat in India this year pushed up electricity use to unprecedented highs, causing widespread power cuts as utilities scrambled to meet demand amid dwindling coal supplies.

Officials at power distribution companies say they are walking a tightrope in their day-to-day dealings with generation firms as they clear just about enough debts to keep the power supply online.

Pachdongri gets its power from the state-run Maharashtra State Electricity Distribution Co. Ltd (MSEDCL), which warned its 30 million consumers last December it would disconnect supplies for those who did not pay their bills.

The utility cited “an unprecedented amount of arrears and increasing financial burden” as a threat to its very existence.

Vijay Singhal, MSEDCL chairman and managing director, said his company had to purchase power to provide it to consumers.

“I am asking people to pay up as I am not getting it for free,” he added.

Data from MSEDCL shows rural consumers owe it more than 600 billion rupees ($7.53 billion), ten times more than unpaid dues from urban consumers of 62 billion rupees.

Singhal said MSEDCL used hydro-power during this year’s heat waves and is adding wind and solar energy to overcome coal shortages and cut costs.

Local officials who turned off the power supply to Pachdongri in Maharashtra’s Amravati district said they had informed the village council about the impending cut if it failed to pay at least some of its dues.

The power was restored within a day, they added.

“If they have used power, they need to pay for it,” said Dilip Khanande, superintending engineer for MSEDCL in Amravati.

Officials at Jal Jeevan Mission, a pan-India project to ensure every rural household gets 55 litres of water per capita per day, estimated that about 40 per cent of village councils’ power bills are linked to operating water pumps.

Khanande said he was able to recover only half of monthly bills of about 10 million rupees accrued for running about 2,000 rural water connections in his district.

Rural reality

Power availability in rural areas has gone up to about 22.5 hours daily from about 12.5 hours in 2015, with all villages now electrified, the central government said this year.

But as long-awaited electricity and water connections reach more rural areas, the cost of consuming the resources has risen.

“We are looking at solar-based water pumps so they don’t require electricity connection to avoid these challenges,” said Hrishikesh Yashod, Maharashtra director for Jal Jeevan Mission.

With water pumps running more to supply household taps, power consumption has gone up and so have councils’ electricity bills, said Yusuf Kabir, a water and health specialist with the U.N children’s agency, UNICEF, in Maharashtra.

Samit Mitra, programme head for Smart Power India, a Rockefeller Foundation subsidiary that works to boost electricity access in rural India, said poor collection is often rooted in infrequent billing and billing amounts that do not reflect consumption, denting consumer trust.

“We see the intention to pay is there. All they need is a certain level of service,” Mitra said.

UNICEF’s Kabir suggested installing water meters so households pay taxes on their consumption, which would improve village councils’ revenue collection to help cover power bills.

Contaminated water

Residents of Pachdongri village had hoped the completion of the tap water project in July would lead to a steady supply and end their dependence for drinking water on a well 2 km away.

Farmer Akshay Amode, 24, saw clean water gush from his household tap the first time a day before power was cut.

The villagers then resorted to well water again - but it was contaminated with sewage due to runoff triggered by heavy rains, said health officials who tested the water.

About 200 people took ill after drinking it and five died, officials said.

Among them was Sahdev Ramaji Akhande’s wife, who had yet to see a running tap in her home.

The 32-year-old farmer, a father of two, recalled the night his wife writhed in pain as he struggled to organise a private car to rush her to hospital.

Three days after she died, Akhande’s home got a tap water connection. But the supply is still intermittent, so he drinks water from tankers serving the village since the cholera outbreak and buys water for his farm.

He knew nothing of another impending expense: the village council - yet to pay its outstanding power bill - is mulling a doubling of the monthly water tax from 100 rupees per household.

“Life has become difficult,” said the widower, now left to bring up his children alone.

This story was published with permission from Thomson Reuters Foundation, the charitable arm of Thomson Reuters, that covers humanitarian news, climate change, resilience, women’s rights, trafficking and property rights. Visit

Like this content? Join our growing community.

Your support helps to strengthen independent journalism, which is critically needed to guide business and policy development for positive impact. Unlock unlimited access to our content and members-only perks.

Most popular

Featured Events

Publish your event
leaf background pattern

Transforming Innovation for Sustainability Join the Ecosystem →