COP31’s Finance Day offers no cheaper loans as grants stay scarce for developing Asia

COP31’s Finance Day produced mobilisation targets rather than cheaper money – and the middle-income economies that make up most of developing Asia still receive more than four-fifths of their public climate finance as loans.

Delegates at COP31 on Finance Day
Delegates at the COP31 climate talks in Antalya on Finance Day. Image: UN Climate Change/Kubilay Ciftci

Finance Day at the COP31 climate talks in Antalya ended on 13 November without a new commitment to lower borrowing costs for developing Asia.

From 2016 to 2024, loans accounted for 85 per cent of the public climate finance provided by developed countries to lower-middle-income countries and 87 per cent of that provided to upper-middle-income countries, according to the OECD.

One of the day’s biggest announcements came from British International Investment, Norway’s Norfund and FinDev Canada. The three development finance institutions launched “10by30”, an initiative that aims to support at least US$10 billion in climate and energy transition investment across emerging markets by 2030. The target includes private capital the partners expect to attract. The institutions will share investment pipelines, coordinate due diligence and cooperate on measuring climate and development impacts, but the announcement did not specify lending rates or name recipient countries. 

“Many developing countries are trapped in a downward loop of debt, disaster, and devastating capital costs,” Simon Stiell, Executive Secretary of UN Climate Change, said at the Seventh Biennial High-Level Ministerial Dialogue on Climate Finance.

In Indonesia, the Philippines and Vietnam, the median cost of capital for utility-scale solar projects ranged from 8 to 9.4 per cent in 2024, compared with 5 to 6.5 per cent in advanced economies, according to an International Energy Agency (IEA) survey. The cost of capital reflects both the cost of borrowing and the return equity investors expect. 

The sharpest argument among climate finance practitioners going into the day was about price, according to a commentary published on 12 November by Stephen Hammer, a Senior Fellow in climate finance at the University of Pennsylvania and a former climate policy adviser at the World Bank. One of his tests for Finance Day was whether development bank and private sector announcements came with “lower interest rates, guarantees that genuinely cut borrowing costs, and named countries.”

Cutting the cost of capital by one percentage point would save emerging and developing economies US$150 billion a year in clean energy financing, according to a 2024 IEA estimate.

Finance Day Highlights

  • US$10 billion by 2030, “10by30”: A joint target from British International Investment, FinDev Canada and Norfund, the development finance institutions of the UK, Canada and Norway.
  • C$116 million (US$81 million) from Canada: Funding for 12 climate projects in developing countries, the first allocated under Canada’s new five-year climate finance goal.
  • US$103 billion delivered in 2025: Climate finance from multilateral development banks to low- and middle-income countries, reported in a joint statement. The figure is past delivery, not a new pledge.

The goal of mobilising US$1.3 trillion a year for developing economies by 2035 relies heavily on private investors, who charge more to lend where they see more risk. External climate finance is on track to fall around US$840 billion short of that goal, according to a report released on the eve of the talks by the outgoing COP30 Presidency.

New public climate finance pledges from developed countries average US$11.7 billion a year for the rest of the decade, more than 70 per cent below earlier commitments, according to an analysis by Carbon Brief. Official development assistance, the aid budgets from which most climate grants are drawn, fell 23.1 per cent in 2025, the steepest drop on record, according to the OECD.

Where grants matter 

“Climate-vulnerable countries need grants, not more loans that add to their debt burden,” Bangladesh’s Prime Minister Tarique Rahman said in his address to the summit on 12 November. He also called for clauses that let countries pause repayments after a disaster.

The financing mix was different for low-income countries as grants accounted for about 65 per cent of the public climate finance they received from 2016 to 2024, according to the OECD.

“Loans aren’t necessarily a bad thing. A [renewable energy] project with a reliable buyer and predictable electricity sales should be able to support debt financing,” said Christina Ng, Managing Director of the Energy Shift Institute, an energy finance think tank focused on Southeast and East Asia.

“The difficulty is when countries or utilities are already financially stretched, or when the investments are important for the electricity system but don’t generate sufficient revenue to repay the loans,” she added.

The grids and storage that more solar and wind capacity needs may not pay their way under existing electricity market arrangements, in which case more loans could add to the burden on utilities or governments, according to Ng. That leaves grants and highly concessional finance an important role in preparing projects, clearing infrastructure bottlenecks and funding investments that are necessary but hard to finance commercially, in her view.

“What we are observing right now in the name of climate finance is debt by design,” said M. Zakir Hossain Khan, Co-founder and Chief Executive of Change Initiative, a Dhaka-based think tank, at a COP31 policy dialogue on Saturday.

Khan was also sceptical of leaning on private capital. “The private sector is important, particularly for technology and manufacturing, but adaptation finance should not be left to private markets or profit motives,” he said at an earlier press conference on 10 November.

The poorest developing countries, those eligible for the World Bank’s cheapest loans, paid an average of 8.2 per cent on new loans from private lenders in 2025, the highest rate since 1989, and 9.4 per cent on new bonds, against 5.5 per cent for better-off developing countries borrowing on standard terms, according to the World Bank’s International Debt Report 2026, published earlier this month. Laos priced bonds maturing in 2030 at 11.25 per cent.

Developing countries are taking on more debt at a higher price, often leaving less money for long-term development, according to Haishan Fu, the World Bank’s Chief Statistician.

Simon Stiell at COP31, Finance Day

Simon Stiell, Executive Secretary of UN Climate Change, at the COP31 climate talks in Antalya. Image: Kubilay Ciftci/UN Climate Change

Grid and permit risks raise Southeast Asia’s costs

Higher borrowing costs can make renewable power more expensive, but they are only one reason projects stall in Southeast Asia.

“Higher financing costs can make an otherwise competitive renewable energy project less attractive to utilities or developers, or result in higher electricity prices. But we should also be careful not to attribute Southeast Asia’s slow progress entirely to expensive financing,” said the Energy Shift Institute’s Ng. 

Before weighing interest rates, investors need to know who will buy the electricity, whether that buyer can pay and whether the grid has room to carry it, according to Ng.

“If those basic conditions aren’t in place, even a cheap loan won’t necessarily get the project built,” Ng said. 

Financiers surveyed by the IEA put Southeast Asia’s higher costs down to regulatory, political, transmission and permitting risks.

In Vietnam, developers often absorb the losses when a congested grid forces solar farms to cut output, with state utility EVN sharing little of that risk. In Indonesia, much of the lending comes from international lenders in US dollars, so rising US interest rates feed straight into project costs.

Countries that have scaled up clean energy investment, such as Brazil, India and South Africa, relied heavily on capital raised at home, according to the agency.

Concessional finance still has a role, and the IEA estimates it has to more than triple, to around US$115 billion a year in 2030–2035, for energy transitions in emerging economies. Used as well-structured de-risking, each public dollar can draw in US$3 to US$7 of private capital, according to the agency.

“The US$10 billion initiative is a welcome commitment. But I’d be interested in how much of that financing helps address these underlying problems and enables investments that would otherwise struggle to proceed,” Ng said.

Draft deal calls for ‘debt pause clauses’

A draft decision released by the COP31 Presidency on 18 November lists high costs of capital, limited fiscal space and unsustainable debt levels among the barriers developing countries face. It calls for more grant-based and non-debt-creating finance, and for “debt pause clauses in loan agreements, taking into account debt burdens and the inequity of debt-financed adaptation”.

The World Bank already offers such clauses to 45 small island and other small states, 22 of which had signed up by April, according to its Director for Climate, Jamie Fergusson. Larger Asian borrowers such as Bangladesh, Indonesia, the Philippines and Vietnam are not eligible.

Ministers are negotiating the text this week, and the talks are scheduled to close on Friday. As drafted, it calls for debt pause clauses but commits no new money to make borrowing cheaper.

Most popular

Featured Events

Publish your event
leaf background pattern

Transforming Innovation for Sustainability Join the Ecosystem →

Strategic Organisations

NVPC Singapore Company of Good logo
First Gen
NZCA