DBS is first Asian bank to launch climate policy—but it’s still funding coal

The Singapore-based bank has pledged to stop financing coal power projects—but only in developed countries. An NGO has said the policy “changes nothing” about the bank’s efforts to tackle climate change.

Southeast Asia’s largest bank DBS last week launched a climate policy — becoming the first bank in the region to do so.

Its new policy, published on the same day that Singapore declared 2018 to be the Year of Climate Action, consists of four pledges to tackle climate change, Eco-Business can reveal.

They include a commitment to reduce the bank’s own environmental footprint, promote sustainable finance, lend responsibly, and make climate-related financial disclosures.

In its responsible lending pledge, the Singapore-based bank says it will stop financing new coal-fired power stations in countries belonging to the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), a club of developed countries that includes the United States, United Kingdom, Japan, South Korea and Australia.

But this means that DBS, which uses the advertising slogan “Living, breathing Asia,” will continue to finance coal power in developing countries such as Vietnam and Indonesia. 

Burning coal is the biggest contributor to greenhouse gas emissions, and the most powerful force driving climate change—which is predicted to hurt Southeast Asia more than anywhere.

But coal is still the dominant source of power to fuel the region’s fast-growing economies, even though renewable energy has been cited as a viable alternative.

The bank stated that it will “change its focus to more efficient technologies” for coal projects in developing countries, and will stop financing new coal mines.

DBS’s pledge does not affect any of the coal projects that it is currently financing.

DBS thinks it’s okay for wealthy countries to enjoy the economic and environmental benefits of renewable energy while poor countries can keep having their air polluted.

Julien Vincent, executive director, Market Forces

DBS, which was the first Asian bank to commit to sourcing all of its energy from renewable sources in September last year, is the first financial institution in the region to unveil a climate policy. 

It does so three weeks after a report from green group Market Forces pointed out that the bank is continuing to fund coal projects across the region in a year that the Singapore government—which founded DBS Bank 50 years ago—has declared the Year of Climate Action.

Market Forces’ report showed that DBS has been involved in 12 coal deals worth a total of $885 million since 2012, and is currently co-financing four 1200 MW coal-fired power plants in Vietnam. It is also a financial adviser for three planned coal-fired projects in Indonesia.

DBS’s policy is similar to the one introduced by London-headquartered HSBC three months ago. The international banking giant rolled out a US$100 million sustainable finance programme that included four pledges to tackle climate change, including a commitment to stop financing coal in developed countries.

Like HSBC, DBS in its policy promises to introduce environmental, social and governance (ESG) funds, and encourage “green consumer behaviour” through the products it markets to its customers.

Accompanying DBS’s policy is a statement from company chief executive Piyush Gupta, who said that the bank recognises its role in promoting sustainable development, including the transition to a low-carbon economy.

“Climate change affects us all and we seek to do our part to ensure a clean energy future. It is with this in mind that we have pledged to support Singapore’s ‘Year of Climate Action’. I believe that our commitments will result in substantial impact in the years to come,” he said.

But Julien Vincent, executive director, Market Forces, said that the bank’s policy “changes nothing” about its involvement with the coal industry.

“Currently, DBS is involved in banking syndicates for new polluting coal power stations, and their policy would not take the bank out of a single one,” he told Eco-Business.  “Of course it’s important that banks start talking more about the environmental, social and financial risks attached to coal and DBS is the first to move in that regard,” he acknowledged.

“But there is a deep cynicism in coming out with language that might look like DBS is acting, but the practical application is that nothing has to change,” Vincent said. 

He pointed out that DBS’s policy excludes coal power plants in OECD countries, where DBS is not involved in the sector, yet keeps the door open for polluting coal in developing countries. “This suggests that DBS thinks it’s okay for wealthy countries to enjoy the economic and environmental benefits of renewable energy while poor countries can keep having their air polluted,” he said.

Vincent said it was “unacceptable” for DBS to be funding an industry that is responsible for claiming thousands of lives every year in Southeast Asia due to air pollution, while renewable energy “offers a cost effective, clean development alternative to coal.”

He added that DBS’ policy will be put to the test in the coming two months, as the Nghi Son 2 coal power plant in Vietnam attempts to reach financial close. If DBS finances the 1,200 megawatt plant, it will show that its climate policy means “business as usual” for a bank that has long funded fossil fuel power projects, Vincent said. 

In response to questions about its climate policy, the bank’s chief sustainability officer Mikkel Larsen quoted International Energy Agency data that shows that while Southeast Asia is taking steps towards adopting low-carbon energy, by 2040 coal is still expected to account for 40 per cent of the region’s energy mix.

“Many of our neighbouring developing countries are dependent on coal as part of their energy mix to deliver economic growth, and the financial system has a responsibility to ensure that the transition to renewables happens in a sustainable manner,” he said.

In addition to outlining DBS’ policy on coal, Larsen added that the bank would stop financing new coal mines, and would “only support clients who have a diversification strategy.”  

“DBS will honour the commitments to current customers,” he said.

The financing of new coal fired power plants should be restricted to low income countries with no available alternative – as assessed by independent third-parties

Jeanne Stamp, head, Asia sustainable finance and commodities, WWF

Best of a bad bunch

DBS performed relatively well in a report on the sustainability of Asean’s banks by World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF) in October last year—but it was best bank in a poorly performing sector.

The report’s author, Jeanne Stampe, head, Asia sustainable finance and commodities, WWF, told Eco-Business that to truly enable the region’s transition to sustainable energy, banks like DBS have a responsibility to ensure that their policies promote “true disclosure”.

Full financial disclosure means that the banks report their financing mix for the energy sector and set targets for how this will shift over time, she said. In line with this, energy sector clients should be required to set science-based targets.

“The financing of new coal fired power plants should be restricted to low income countries with no available alternative – as assessed by independent third-parties,” she said. “Such policies should also include underwriting and corporate lending, in addition to project financing.”

Thanks for reading to the end of this story!

We would be grateful if you would consider joining as a member of The EB Circle. This helps to keep our stories and resources free for all, and it also supports independent journalism dedicated to sustainable development. It only costs as little as S$5 a month, and you would be helping to make a big difference.

Find out more and join The EB Circle

Advertisement
Asia Pacific’s Hub For Collaboration On Sustainable Development
An Eco-Business initiative
The SDG Co